Top 5 Fan Theories About Valdrova

Six chapters in, and the My Slain Dragon Bride fandom has done what fandoms do: produced a stack of theories about Valdrova that are smarter, sadder, and stranger than anything the manhwa has officially said. Here are the five we keep coming back to on the Discord.

5. Valdrova Has Been Trying to Die for Centuries

The simplest read. Valdrova is ancient, weary, and has been ready to stop for a very long time. The reason no one has ever claimed the heart that unlocks the 9th Circle is not because the warriors are weak — it is because he has been choosing when and how to lose.

Evidence for:

• “Just acceptance, as if he had been waiting for this moment for centuries.”
• The fact that he knows Perda’s name before she introduces herself.

Evidence against:

• If he wanted to die, why wait this long? There has to be a reason it had to be her.

4. The Heart Inside Her Chest Is Still Listening

The most-read theory on the wiki. Valdrova’s heart is now physically inside Perda’s body, beating alongside hers. The manhwa has not yet shown whether the heart retains any consciousness — but several lines from the first chapters hint at memories surfacing in moments Perda cannot explain.

Evidence for:

• “She took his heart. She claimed her prize. She should have felt triumph.” — followed immediately by a feeling she cannot name.
• The author’s habit of writing Valdrova in present tense even in the second timeline.

Evidence against:

• It might just be grief. Not every unexplained feeling is a heartbeat that is not her own.

3. The 9th Circle Is Not a Place — It Is a Relationship

The theory that has gained the most traction in the last two chapters. The 9th Circle is described as a realm of demigod-like power. The cost of entry is the heart of the Crimson Dragon. The manhwa has not yet explained what the 9th Circle actually is — only what it costs.

What if it is not a room? What if it is a state? The heart inside her chest is the door. The door opens only when she accepts what she has done. In other words, the 9th Circle is reached not by killing, but by understanding.

Evidence for:

• The word circle is geometric and enclosed — it does not behave like a place.
• Perda is a 9th Circle mage on paper, but the manhwa keeps describing her as hollow.

Evidence against:

• It is also possible the author is keeping the 9th Circle as a literal place for a future arc reveal.

2. The Engagement Announcement Was Always the Happy Ending

The most romantic theory. The nobles’ “death sentence” — become engaged to the public king Valdrova — was, in retrospect, the only path that saved both leads. The manhwa opens with Perda having killed Valdrova. The manhwa rewinds to a moment where she can choose differently. The very fact that the rewind exists, on this theory, is the universe giving her the chance to say the word she could not say.

Evidence for:

• The author chose to make the engagement announcement the inciting scene of the second timeline. Not the killing. Not the 9th Circle. The marriage.
• “Understood” is the only word in the engagement scene that the author lets land as a complete line.

Evidence against:

• It might just be a political marriage with a tragic outcome. The manhwa has not yet tipped its hand.

1. Valdrova Wanted to Be Carried by Her

The most heartbreaking theory. Valdrova cannot love Perda in life — the engagement, the political marriage, the centuries of waiting, none of it lets him be a husband in any way that would satisfy him. So he chooses a different ending. He lets her kill him. He gives her his heart. He asks her, in the only way an immortal can, to carry him with her.

Evidence for:

• The line “To think my own fiancée would come to take my life” reads differently on this theory. It is not a complaint. It is a recognition. She is, finally, doing what he could not ask her to do while he was alive.
• The heart inside her chest is described, repeatedly, as something she cannot put down.

Evidence against:

• It is also entirely possible the author is going to subvert this in the second timeline, where he is alive and beside her and the heart is still in his chest.

What the Next Chapters Need to Answer

For any of these theories to land, the next few chapters need to do one of two things:

• Confirm or deny whether the heart inside Perda’s chest is conscious. This is the single biggest open question. If Valdrova can still talk to her from inside her own body, the rest of the theory stack collapses or rearranges around that fact.
• Show us a Valdrova moment in the second timeline that does not match the first. If he is different — softer, more afraid, more present — the second-timeline Valdrova may be the answer to whether the first-timeline Valdrova was choosing his own death.

How to Add Your Theory

Drop it in the Discord. The most-read theories get folded into the next wiki update. If your theory holds up after chapter 7, it will probably be on next month’s list.

---

These theories are ranked by raw Discord message volume as of the most recent chapter drop. As always: bring tissues.